Curtin argues that the so-called green
revolution destroys the environment and poses a threat to peace. Truman's
developmentalist vision for the "third world" is an early instance of the
green revolution, and its impact on the environment may be contrasted with
that of the ideal of village swaraj espoused by Gandhi.
The green revolution brings "first-world"
agricultural practices to the "third world." Those who introduce the green
revolution, however, dominate and make war on the environment. Curtin refers
to the practices associated with the green revolution as developmentalism
and warism.
Among the "warist" practices are the
clear-cutting of the land, single crops rather than rotating crops, the
elimination of mixed animal and vegetable farming, an excessive demand
for water, the use of chemical fertilizers, a dependency on hybrid seed,
and the industrialization of farming. Large amounts of cash are needed
for this type of farming, and loans are made available to farmers. In the
"underdeveloped" third world, these loans may be given through the World
Bank. The process is "top down"--with the wealthy few at the top reaping
profits from the labor of the many at the bottom.
The communitarian ideal of village
swaraj as proposed by Gandhi treats the land in a more cooperative,
sustainable way than the farming that accompanies the green revolution.
The preservation of trees on some lands helps control flooding. Crop rotation
contributes to the control of insects by removing their food supply. Mixed
animal and vegetable farming provides renewable organic materials in place
of chemical fertilizers. Since hybrid seeds are largely infertile, farmers
become completely dependent on corporate suppliers of seeds for their
crops. The use of animals rather than mechanized farming keeps down cash
costs.
Women grow the vast majority of the
food in third world countries, and traditionally women have used organic,
cooperative methods of farming. Women's agriculture is pacificist and cooperative
rather than aggressive and competitive in its approach to nature. "Treatment
of the land reveals the moral self." The green revolution threatens women's
agriculture in the third world.
The green revolution seeks to impose
the practice of Western industrialized farming on the entire world. Its
attitude may be described as one of "arrogant perception." Women's agriculture
is local and has a close relationship with a specific place.
The green revolution sought to defeat
communism by destroying the world's peasant class. Reactions against this
have emerged in the Liberation Theology in Central America and Dalit Theology
in India. In both one finds a pacificism that is a form of resistance to
threats to communities and environments.