Singer argues that people have an obligation
to prevent suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, and medical
care, regardless of where such suffering and death occurs in the world.
His argument takes the following form.
If we can prevent something bad without sacrificing anything of comparable
significance, we ought to do it; suffering and death from lack of food,
shelter, and medical care is bad; there is some suffering and death from
lack of food, shelter, and medical care we can prevent without sacrificing
anything of comparable moral signifance; therefore, we ought to prevent
some suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, and medical care.
The obligation to relieve suffering and death from these causes need not
reduce one to the hardship level, but the obligation arises when abundance
is present--as Thomas Aquinas argues.
Singer subscribes to a form of
utilitarianism that allows property rights to be overridden to prevent
great evils. Although he favors the more stringent requirement that the
affluent are required to give for famine relief unless they must sacrifice
something of comparable moral significance, he is willing to accept the
more moderate view that the affluent are required to give as long as they
don't sacrifice anything of moral significance. Even the fulfillment of
this more moderate requirement would result in a great change in the way
of life of citizens of weathy nations.
Singer finds that many people do not
think along the lines he proposes on matters of poverty relief. Some who
subscribe to a community-based morality, for example, hold that one should
assist members of one's own community, but relief for strangers is not
as demanding. Singer rejects this community-oriented view in favor of universal
liberal standards. Although his own preference is for the utilitarian standard
of impartiality or equal treatment, Singer notes that a Kantian standard
of universalizability would also support the claim that all persons in
serious need are entitled to relief regardless of their geographical proximity.